Appeal

M-71/2016 M-71/2016 of February 25, 2016 in case No. 2-98 / 2016

In the name of the Russian Federation

February 25, 2016 Kem

Kem City Court of the Republic of Karelia, composed of:

presiding judge I. Yashkova,

with the participation of the public prosecutor Panova AND.A.,

when Secretary Bahur L.N.,

examined in open court a civil case on the claim Petrachenkova C.T. to the administration of the Kemsky city settlement, limited liability company “Nord-Wood” to recover material damage, pecuniary damage,

Petrachenkova S.T. appealed to the court with the administration of the Kemsky city settlement for compensation for harm caused to her on 11/13/2015 as a result of damage to health when falling on a slippery sidewalk near the house. The plaintiff believes that she was injured in connection with the improper fulfillment by the administration of the authority to maintain the road-bridge economy on the territory of the Kemsky urban settlement, as well as inadequate control over the company that maintains the road-bridge economy. The plaintiff asks to recover from the defendant the cost of medicines in the amount of., Pecuniary damage in the amount of.

The court, as a co-defendant in the case, involved LLC Nord-Wood.

The plaintiff Petrachenkova C.T., her representative Heikin O.E., acting on the basis of an oral statement recorded in the minutes of the court session, at the hearing the claim was fully supported on the grounds set out in the statement of claim. Petrachenkova S.T. explained that on November 13, 2015, in the area of ​​the house, while on the sidewalk, she slipped and fell. As a result of the fall, she hit her head hard. After work, the state of health sharply worsened, headache intensified, nausea and dizziness appeared. On November 15, 2015, she turned to the emergency room of the Central District Hospital, as the condition did not change, headache, nausea and dizziness persisted. On November 16, 2015, she turned to the Kem Central District Hospital, where she was sent for a head x-ray. On November 17, 2015, she turned to a neurologist, was diagnosed with November 13, 2015, and she was referred for inpatient treatment at the surgical department of the Kem Central District Hospital. From November 17 to November 24, 2015 she was hospitalized with a clinical diagnosis of:. After treatment, the headaches disappeared, but dizziness persisted. After discharge from the hospital, she continues to take medications recommended by doctors, which she purchases at her own expense.

The administration of the Kemsky urban settlement did not send their representative to the court session, they were duly notified of the time and place of the court session, a motion was filed to consider the case in the absence of a representative. In the objections to the statement of claim, the defendant filed a petition to attract Nord-Wood LLC as a defendant in the case, since the administration of the Kemsky city settlement on January 29, 2015, in order to ensure the fulfillment of the powers of local authorities of the Kemsky city settlement to resolve issues of local importance regarding road of activity with Nord-Wood LLC a municipal contract No. has been concluded for the performance of work on the current maintenance, maintenance and operation of road bridge facilities farm on the territory of the Kem city settlement for the needs of the administration of the Kem city settlement. The contractor, LLC Nord-Wood, undertook to carry out on its own and, at its discretion, efforts to maintain, maintain and operate road bridge facilities on the territory of the Kemsky urban settlement. Thus, the plaintiff’s injury is in a causal relationship with the improper performance of Nord-Wood LLC of its obligations under municipal contract No. 29.012015, expressed in failure to take measures to clean the sidewalks from snow and ice formations in the area of ​​the house in winter, and not through the fault of the administration of the Kem city settlement.

The representative of Nord-Wood LLC Director Popov D.N. at the hearing he objected to the satisfaction of the claims. He explained that, based on the municipal contract of January 29, 2015, Nord-Wood LLC carries out maintenance, maintenance and operation of road-bridge facilities on the territory of the Kemsky municipal district, including backfilling, despite the fact that the data works are not provided for by the municipal contract. The sidewalk near the house is located along the highway, ice on it formed at night from 11/12/2015 to 11/13/2015 due to lower temperatures. The slippery on this sidewalk was removed within the standard period established by GOST, which for roads of this category is 6 hours.

In conclusion, the deputy prosecutor of the Kemsky district Panov I.A. He considered the claims to be satisfied by the administration of the Kemsky city settlement and Nord-Wood LLC.

The court, having heard the plaintiff and his representative, the defendant, testimonies of witnesses, the opinion of the prosecutor, having studied the materials of this civil case, comes to the following.

In accordance with the provisions of Article Section IV Certain types of obligations> Chapter 59. Obligations as a result of harm> § 1. General provisions on compensation for harm> Article 1064. General grounds for liability for harm 'target =' _ blank '> 1064 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation damage caused to the person or property of a citizen, and Also, the damage caused to the property of a legal entity shall be compensated in full by the person who caused the harm. The person who caused the harm shall be exempted from compensation for harm if he proves that the harm was caused not through his fault.

It was established that on 11/13/2015 at about seven in the morning the plaintiff walked along the sidewalk in the area of ​​the house, slipped and fell, having hit the back of the head on ice. Gavrilova T.A. walked behind, helped her up and get to the place of work. As a result of the fall, the plaintiff received a concussion. These circumstances are confirmed by the plaintiff’s explanations, witness statements.

So, the witness questioned during the trial, showed that she is a colleague of the plaintiff, 11/13/2015 she went to work on the street. I saw a woman who was trying to get up from the sidewalk, crying. She walked over, recognized the plaintiff, helped her up, pack her things and get to work. Petrachenkova S.T. complained of severe headache, nausea, dizziness. The witness explained that this road runs every day, the sidewalk was slippery all week, not sprinkled. Returning home from work, the sidewalk was also not sprinkled, she moved with great difficulty.

Witness., Questioned during the trial, testified that he is the spouse of the plaintiff. November 13, 2015 was absent in the city of Kemi, was in the city. The wife said on the phone that she had fallen, slipping on the sidewalk on the way to work. He called the director of Nord-Wood LLC, D.N. Popov, and made a complaint about the improper maintenance of roads in the city of Kemi. The next day, November 14, 2015, his son drove along the street on which the plaintiff fell, the sidewalk was sprinkled.

The court has no reason to question the truth of the facts reported by the witnesses., Since they are consistent, do not contradict each other, there is no evidence of any interest of these witnesses in the outcome of the present case.

In connection with the fall, the plaintiff was hospitalized from 11/17/2015 to 11/24/2015, outpatient treatment from 11/25/2015 to 12/11/2015, as evidenced by the outpatient card Petrachenkova S.T., disability sheets.

Thus it is the court finds established the fact of damage to the health of the plaintiff.

The plaintiff to recovery claimed the amount of damage. (). The plaintiff's need for these medications is confirmed by a prescription and an outpatient card. In evidence of the money spent on the purchase of medicines, the court presented cash and sales receipts for the purchase of the amount.

The court considers proved the amount of harm inflicted in the amount., Since it is confirmed by the evidence presented in the case. Evidence of the acquisition of other drugs by the plaintiff the court is not presented.

According to Art. 2 of the Federal Law of 10.12.1995 No. 196-ФЗ "On Road Safety", the road is a strip of land equipped or used and used for the movement of vehicles or the surface of an artificial structure. A road includes one or several carriageways, as well as tram tracks, sidewalks, curbs and dividing lanes, if any. Road user - a person directly involved in the road traffic as a driver of a vehicle, pedestrian, passenger of a vehicle.

In accordance with Art. (as amended on 12/27/2018)> "On Road Safety"> (as amended and additional, entered into force on 12/30/2018)> Chapter I. General Provisions> Article 3. Basic Principles for Ensuring Road Safety ' target = '_ blank'> 3 of the Federal Law “On Road Traffic Safety” one of the basic principles for ensuring road safety is the priority of life and health of citizens participating in road traffic over economic results of economic activity.

Repair and maintenance of roads in the Russian Federation should ensure road safety. Compliance of the condition of roads with technical regulations and other regulatory documents related to road safety is confirmed by acts of control inspections or surveys of roads conducted with the participation of relevant executive authorities (Clause 1, Art. (As amended on 12/27/2018)> "On Safety "> (as amended and supplemented, entered into force on 12/30/2018)> Chapter IV. Basic requirements for ensuring road safety> Article 12. Basic requirements for ensuring road safety when Repairing and maintenance of roads' target = '_ blank'> 12 of the Federal Law "On Road Traffic Safety").

By virtue of paragraph 3 of Art. (as amended on 12/27/2018)> "On Road Safety"> (as amended and additional, entered into force on 12/30/2018)> Chapter IV. Basic requirements for ensuring road safety> Article 24. Rights and obligations of road users' target = '_ blank'> 24 of the Federal Law on Road Safety, road users are entitled to compensation for damage on the grounds and in the manner established the legislation of the Russian Federation, in cases of bodily injury.

01/29/2015 between the administration of the Kemsky city settlement and Nord-Wood LLC a municipal contract was concluded, the subject of which was the obligation to carry out work on the maintenance, maintenance and operation of road bridge facilities on the territory of the Kemsky city settlement.

Appendix No. 1 to the contract defines the winter maintenance of road-bridge facilities, including cleaning sidewalks of snow and ice formations, as well as a list of roads, including ul. .

Having assessed the evidence presented, the court concludes that Nord-Wood LLC is the proper defendant in the case, since the injury sustained by the plaintiff is a consequence of the improper maintenance of the sidewalk on ul. .

LLC “Nord-Wood” did not submit to the court evidence of the absence of guilt in causing harm to the plaintiff, as well as evidence of causing this damage due to force majeure, or damage to the health of the plaintiff in other circumstances or intent of the plaintiff.

In accordance with the provisions approved by the Decree of the State Standard of the Russian Federation No. 221 dated October 11, 1993 GOST R 50597-93 “Roads and streets. Requirements for operational conditions acceptable under the conditions of ensuring road safety ”, pavement and pedestrian walkways should be clean and free of foreign objects not related to their arrangement. The requirements of this standard should be provided by organizations in charge of roads, streets and roads of cities and other settlements, and if the operational condition of roads (including their individual elements) and streets does not meet the requirements of the standard, they must be entered time restrictions ensuring safety, up to a complete ban on traffic, including pedestrians.

Based on the foregoing, the court concludes that the damage to the health of the plaintiff is in direct causal connection with the improper performance of the Nord-Wood LLC operations on the current maintenance, maintenance and operation of road bridge facilities on the territory of the Kemsky city settlement in accordance with the terms of the municipal contract.

According to Art. Section I. General Provisions> Subsection 3. Objects of Civil Rights> Chapter 8. Intangible Goods and Their Protection> Article 151. Compensation of moral damage 'target =' _ blank '> 151 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation if moral damage is caused to a citizen (physical or moral suffering ) by actions that violate his personal non-property rights or infringe on intangible goods belonging to a citizen, as well as in other cases provided for by law, the court may impose on the offender the obligation of monetary compensation for the specified damage. In determining the amount of compensation for non-pecuniary damage, the court takes into account the degree of guilt of the offender and other circumstances noteworthy. The court must also take into account the degree of physical and moral suffering associated with the individual characteristics of the injured citizen.

According to paragraph 2 of Art. Section IV Certain types of obligations> Chapter 59. Obligations as a result of harm> § 4. Compensation for moral harm> Article 1101. Method and amount of compensation for moral damage 'target =' _ blank '> 1101 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation the amount of compensation for moral damage is determined by the court, depending on the nature of the damage to the victim of physical and moral suffering, as well as the degree of guilt of the inflicter of harm in cases where guilt is the basis for compensation for harm. In determining the amount of compensation for harm, the requirements of reasonableness and justice must be taken into account.

The nature of the physical and moral suffering is assessed by the court taking into account the factual circumstances in which the non-pecuniary damage was caused and the individual characteristics of the victim.

In view of the circumstances, as well as the principle of reasonableness and justice, the court considers it possible to determine the amount of compensation for non-pecuniary damage caused to the plaintiff, in view of the damage to her health, in the amount.

By virtue of subparagraph 3 of paragraph 1 of Article Section VIII. Federal taxes> Chapter 25.3. State duty> Article 333.36. Benefits when applying to the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, courts of general jurisdiction, magistrates' target = '_ blank'> 333.36 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation, plaintiffs are exempted from paying the state duty in cases considered in courts of general jurisdiction, as well as magistrates compensation for damage caused by injury or other damage to health, as well as the death of a breadwinner.

Thus, in this case, the plaintiff was exempted from paying the state fee, and therefore paid by the plaintiff when filing a lawsuit. subject to return in accordance with article ZZZ. Section IV General rules for the fulfillment of the obligation to pay taxes, fees, insurance contributions> Chapter 7. Objects of taxation> Article 40. Principles for determining the price of goods, work or services for tax purposes' target = '_ blank'> 40 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation.

By virtue of Article 1 of Section I. General Provisions> Chapter 1. General Provisions> Article 10. Publicity of the Trial 'target =' _ blank '> 10З of the Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation the state duty, from the payment of which the plaintiff was released, is recovered from the defendant exempted from the payment of court costs, in proportion to the satisfied part of the claims.

Thus it is subject to collection from the Nord-Wood LLC to the budget of the Kem municipal district in the amount of a state fee. ().

Claims Petrachenkova C.T. partially limited liability company “Nord-Wood”.

To recover from the limited liability company “Nord-Wood” in compensation for harm caused by damage to health, compensation for moral damage.

Collect from the limited liability company "Nord-Wood" in the budget of the Kem municipal district the state fee in the amount of.

The claim to the administration of the Kem city settlement to refuse.

The decision can be appealed to the appeal to the Supreme Court of the Republic of Karelia through the Kem City Court of the Republic of Karelia within one month from the date of the decision in final form.

Referee I.S. Yashkova

The motivated decision was made on February 29, 2016.

«Непредсказуемая» кассация

Кассация - самый непредсказуемый этап обжалования несправедливого или «неугодного» судебного акта. Зачастую, кассационная инстанция оставляет без изменения судебные решения с явными признаками нарушений. Особенно это касается судов общей юрисдикции. Но почему так происходит? Ведь суд обязан защищать интересы «ущемленной» в правах стороны.

There are two answers to this question. If we talk about district courts, today the cassation appeal, as a rule, takes place in the same subject of the Russian Federation where the initial decision was made. For example, a complaint about a district court decision that has entered into force is forwarded to the presidium of a court of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation (supreme, regional, territorial, and so on) where this court operates. This is required by Article 377 Code of Civil Procedure of the Russian Federation. And if the court of the subject begins to cancel the decisions of its lower instances one by one, then this will sharply worsen the statistics and raise questions from the Supreme Court from Moscow. It was this situation that led to the next reform of the judicial system of the Russian Federation, which began last year. In more detail about it we will tell a little lower.

If we talk about arbitration courts of cassation, they cancel much more decisions than their colleagues from the sphere of general jurisdiction. This is because they are not connected by “regional” interests and may occupy a more independent position. However, here everything is not so smooth. Often the notorious judicial “corporatism” seriously affects decision-making (many judges of the cassation and appeal instances know each other in person or in absentia), as well as the established practice. Well, there's nothing to be done.

The second reason that the cassation court does not always annul decisions of lower courts is that it is based on the content of the cassation appeal and on the arguments presented therein. In addition, she checks the legality of the court decision. In simple words, the court of cassation will not (and is not required to) study the circumstances of the case in detail and assess the accuracy of the assessment of evidence in the case by the "previous" instances.

The court of cassation does not have the right to review facts and circumstances already assessed by previous instances if the assessment was carried out in compliance with substantive and procedural law. Further, he cannot collect additional evidence and attract new defendants to participate in the case.

As a result of baboutmost of these complaints are not satisfied at all by the courts. This postulate particularly vividly illustrates the activities of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation as a cassation instance. So, according to statistics, the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation satisfy only 1, 35% of such complaints received in his address. That is, on average, only 1 complaint out of 100! This is a very low percentage. Most of the complaints received are not even referred to the appropriate board of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. The responsible judge, having examined the documents, makes a ruling on the refusal to refer the case to the cassation instance. That's it. (Definition of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation No. 11-KG18-38 dated 12/14/2018).

In what cases can a cancellation of an appeal order or a judicial act of first instance be possible?

The cancellation of a decision that has entered into force can be counted on if the rules were violated during the consideration of the case and when the decision was made:

substantive law, namely:

• Legislation to be applied has not been applied.
• non-enforceable laws have been applied,
• legislative norms were misinterpreted.

Further, if during the review process procedural rules were violated, for example,

• in the case there is no court record,
• the case was considered by the court in an improper composition,
• Violations of the law on the secrecy of the court hearing,
• the process took place in the absence of one of the obligatory participants in the case without proper notification of the person about the date and place of the court hearing, etc.

Despite the complexity of the appeal procedure, it is quite possible to win a court. But: you need to remember that the correctness of the cassation plays a decisive role in the outcome of the proceedings.

Important:in spite of the fact that the courts of cassation are reluctant to satisfy complaints about decisions taken in two instances, it is worth filing a complaint. The point is not only and not so much whether there are chances to win a case in a cassation instance. Most importantly, the applicant has the opportunity to further appeal the court ruling - the subsequent submission of the application to the President of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation and to the European Court.

Cassation appeal in civil cases of general jurisdiction.

The complaint is sent directly to the cassation instance. Today (that is, at the beginning of 2019), the norms of the Code of Civil Procedure of the Russian Federation still apply, indicating that it, as a rule, is submitted to a higher court of the subject of the Russian Federation.

For example, if a citizen or legal entity appeals an appeal ruling of a court of a subject of the Russian Federation, then he / she sends a complaint to the presidium of the same court. Similarly, decisions of district courts that have entered into force, as well as decisions and court orders of justices of the peace are appealed in a similar way. A party dissatisfied with the verdict passed and entered into legal force will also appeal it to the presidium of the highest court of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation.

At the same time, the current articles make it possible to additionally send a cassation appeal against decisions that have entered into force and definitions of regional courts even in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, when they have already been appealed to the presidium of the court of the subject of the Russian Federation. However, as we already learned above, the Supreme Court considers just over 1% of such complaints. But it's still worth a try. Suddenly your business will fall into this 1%?

Novels in the field of cassation appeal.

In July 2018, the President of the Russian Federation signed constitutional law No. 1-FKZ. This normative act substantially reformes the entire judicial system of Russia. One of the most important novelties of this law is the creation of a cassation court of general jurisdiction in our country. In accordance with it, the Russian Federation is divided into nine districts in each of which its own court of cassation is formed. It will consider complaints against decisions of lower courts and magistrates, which have entered into force, as well as acts of courts of appeal adopted on complaints and submissions to decisions of lower courts.

Based on the foregoing, the presidiums of the courts of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation will lose the right to consider cassation complaints. According to the authors of the law, this will completely eliminate the interest of the cassation instance in upholding the decisions of lower courts and increase the fairness of court verdicts.

However, these standards are not yet valid. The reform is now engaged in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. In 2019, he is due to announce the day the functioning of these ships begins. But in any case, this event will occur before September 1 of this year. In the meantime, everything remains as before.

What decisions can be appealed to the cassation?

On appeal, decisions are appealed:

• entered into force
• for which other appeal options have been exhausted.

“Other options” refers to appeal.

In other words, appeal proceedings are a necessary and sufficient condition for reviewing a decision in a court of cassation, not counting the individual cases indicated in the Code of Civil Procedure and agro-industrial complex.

If the appeal court has been “missed” and the decision has entered into force, the decision of the court of first instance can be appealed to the cassation. In the case of an appeal hearing, when the original decision is left unchanged, the applicant has a choice: appeal the decision of the first instance or the decision of the court of appeal.

How long is it necessary to file a cassation appeal?

It is very important not to miss the deadlines set by law for appeal. In civil matters, it is six, and in arbitration, it is two months.

The calculation of the due date should start from the day following the day the appeal ruling is adopted or from the day the decision of the trial court enters into legal force.

How to write a cassation appeal?

In order to win a court, achieve a review of a case or annul a court decision, it is necessary to draw up a cassation appeal correctly, taking into account the specifics of the proceedings, the powers of the cassation court, the goals of the applicant and the available data on the case.

Despite the fact that the complaint is drawn up in any form, you should adhere to a number of rules for the preparation of this document.

The complaint must indicate:

• details of the court of cassation,
• name of the court that made the appealed decision,
• information about the applicant and the data of the parties to the dispute,
• case number, place and date of the final consideration of the case,

• subject and circumstances of the trial, as well as a summary of appealed decisions. In addition, the Code of Civil Procedure of the Russian Federation, for example, (Art. 378), requires that the applicant specifically indicate the essence of the violations by the lower courts of the material and procedural norms and provide arguments confirming these facts,
• applicant requirements with reference to the relevant provisions of the law,

• list of attached documents.

The following materials are attached to the complaint:

• a certified copy of the appealed court decision,
• receipt of payment of state duty, or documents proving the right to privileges when paying it, or a request for an installment plan, and so on,
• documents that confirm the fact of sending a copy of the complaint to other participants in the process, as well as papers or other materials that they do not have,
• a document confirming the right to submit a cassation, if the complaint is submitted through an authorized person.

Important:the content of the cassation appeal is fundamentally different from the content of the initial statement of claim and appeal. Therefore, it is not necessary to duplicate information and rely on a claim model. The appeal shall be written “from scratch”, taking into account the fact that this authority takes into account exclusively “errors of law”.

Therefore, you should not talk about newly discovered facts and circumstances, as well as bring (and ask to take into account) new evidence in the case.

What to ask for in a cassation?

In a cassation appeal, you can declare a request for a new decision or for referral of the case for a new consideration. Despite the fact that the court of cassation is not actually bound by the reasons for the motion, the judges are unlikely to go beyond the stated requirements. Therefore, the most optimal solution is to ask for the case to be returned to a new trial. In 90% of cases, the case is referred for reconsideration to the court of appeal or the court of first instance, which become more “accommodating” and go towards the applicant in questions of issuing requests and introducing new facts and evidence into the case.

If, however, the court is asked to make a new decision, it must be borne in mind that the cassation instance can only make it if the case in question has all the necessary data to make such a decision, that is, additional evidence is not required, and there is no need to re-evaluate the available data. . Otherwise, the applicant may be refused a new decision.

File cassation yourself

You can file the cassation yourself if you take into account all the procedural nuances of the cassation procedure. It is important to know that any wrongful decision seriously affects the authority of a judge. Therefore, a positive review of court decisions that have entered into force is the exception rather than the rule. Indeed, if an error in the decision takes place, then it must be promptly eliminated even at the stage of the appeal review. Win court of cassation and in subsequent instances - aerobatics even for the most experienced lawyer.

Legal assistance in cassation instance

If you want to win a court in cassation and are in search of reliable qualified legal assistance, then the lawyers of the Gestion company are ready to provide legal support at all stages of the cassation process.

Your trusted lawyer:

• Will explain the nuances of compiling a complaint and appeal to the court of cassation,
• Prepare a cassation appeal taking into account the individual circumstances of the case,
• Will conduct a legal analysis of the situation,
• Introduces examples of successfully resolved cases from judicial practice,
• Build a winning line of defense
• Represent your interests in court,
• Recover missed deadlines for filing a cassation.

To protect your interests in resolving civil arbitration disputes, it is possible for a lawyer to enter the case at any stage of the cassation process.

Preparing for the magic process

A plot for good fortune in court is the direction of energy in the right direction. Everything that surrounds a person and creates the circumstances in which he has to live is filled with the same strength. The conspiracy to win in court works through the direction of energy: a person can influence the decision of higher authorities, ensure good luck and quick success.

The plot works from the first days, so you will not have to wait for belated results. Universal rituals are suitable for both quick trials and serious cases, the fate and welfare of the conspirator depend on their decisions.

A lawsuit is a waste of time and energy. A person goes to court while his case is being considered, invests money in the result. The longer the litigation lasts, the greater the costs that may not pay off. For this reason, using a conspiracy to court effectively if you need to speed up the whole process.

Benefits of litigation conspiracies:

• rituals help to win the case if the plaintiff has no evidence or is in a losing position,
• the slander allows you to prepare correctly (find a lawyer or representative, get to a supportive judge),
• Each stage of the process, the party that reads the plot can turn in its own direction.

To win the trial, a universal conspiracy is used before the start of the long trial. It is read on the eve of filing documents. Time will be successful in the period of the growing moon, when the heavenly body helps in the development of all new affairs.

The plot on the eve of the hearing

Prayers for quick resolution are read on the eve of going to court or a few days before filing. In the first case, they will help to perform well and win over the judge, and in the second, they will help to charge the application and other related documents in the right hands. The conspiracy is read in a whisper so that no one hears. If the court is crowded, the slander is pronounced to itself - outsiders should not know about magical actions.

Before the performance, the conspirator walks along the corridor and methodically repeats the slander:

“The Orthodox world is judged, princes, but boyars are judged. And I, the servant of God (the name of the conspirator) must be judged. My right hand, my right foot, my right thoughts and my deeds are completely right - this has always been and will be. As said, it will come true. Amen".

Read the slander without haste, without changing the order of words in the text. Prayer creates strong energy flows and at the same time protects the conspirator from external influences. You can read the text every day when the conspirator goes to court. An important condition for the conspiracy to work: during the answers in court, you need to clench your right fist, you can not leave your hand unclenched. You can read the text before bedtime if you are scheduled to speak early in the morning.

For cash compensation in court

A plot is useful in cases where a person claims to be compensated. This is a vast area of ​​litigation - cases that end in monetary compensation. Magic will help resolve issues related to moral and material damage. The plot is read before filing a lawsuit and at each meeting.

To win the controversial case, amulets are additionally prepared. These are any gizmos that easily sweep into the courthouse. On the eve of the hearing, the little thing speaks:

“What grief comes, it passes by. On other roads, on other paths. I don’t know that grief, I don’t know it, I defend myself. Amen".

Such an amulet will help to avoid outside influence - this is the strongest defense that will be useful to the plaintiff and defendant.

A plot for success in court

The plot to win in court must be read directly at the hearing. At this time, his strength is greatest. Hex for such a court, where monetary matters are decided, learns by heart. You can not swap words or add wishes from yourself. When the conspirator is in court, he needs to twist the “nevermind” with his right hand. This must be done quietly so that no one sees.

After that, magical strong words are pronounced in a whisper:

“You will be a fig, but I will have full boxes of money, but I will have full houses of gold, full wallets with big money, and chests with silver. I, the servant of God (the name of the conspirator), the prince, I am a merchant, I will be happy and crowned. Amen".

The plot is repeated three times, after which the fist is unclenched. Before such a court case it will be useful to clean the house: if you free up space, a place will appear in the house for the monetary compensation that a person is counting on. The plot is read at every meeting.

Correctly pronounced conspiracy will help to get monetary compensation

Magic for the Respondent

Being a defendant in court is harder than making a claim. Additional protection is needed that will not allow violating his legal rights. In order for the court to justify the person, a conspiracy is used on a makeshift amulet.

The defendant prepares the amulet with his own hands: you can not trust such a responsible matter even to native people. A conspiracy to win the court is read on the finished amulet and before the meeting. The attribute cannot be removed at all times during the trial.

The amulet serves throughout the year, so the necessary ingredients are procured in advance. For him you will need:

• chestnut fruit
• dried tobacco
• dry sage herb.

В плоде каштана проделывается дырка, в которую помещается сухой порошок. Его несложно сделать: перемалываются сушеная трава шалфея и табак. Запечатывается каштан свежим воском церковной свечи. Перед ритуалом, когда заговорщик делает амулет, в обязательном порядке посещается церковь. Ответчик исповедуется, просит высшие силы о помощи и забирает с собой одну свечу. If there is no chestnut at hand, it will not be possible to replace it with another fruit - this is an important attribute on which the plot is read in order to win the trial.

The amulet is spoken like this:

Let (the name of the defendant) step on the court, where the harsh bosses will not be strict with him. As the fire of a candle dies out, let the hatred die out, so the mouths of those who speak evil speech dry out. ”

The attribute is taken to court (they hide it in a pocket or hang it on the neck in the form of an unusual pendant). In court, he should be periodically touched with his left hand. You can’t forget such a thing at home.

Magic for the plaintiff

It is not easy to assert your rights, so a conspiracy to win in a future court will help protect your honor and prove that you are right. One long candle is prepared for the ritual. It is brought from the church or bought at any store. New scissors are also useful, which did not cut anything: you can’t take old things, otherwise the plot before the court will not work for the plaintiff.

Such a conspiracy is being read against any person who has offended: a neighbor, a former loved one or a loved one. This is a universal way to win when the truth is on the side of the plaintiff. The ritual is not suitable to protect the defendant.

On the eve of the hearing, a candle is lit. A ritual is carried out in complete solitude, so that no one would know about magical help. With the help of new scissors, the fire is cut, as if cut. At this moment, the plot reads:

“As the Protection of the Most Holy Theotokos cannot be taken, so may the servant of God (name) be firmly protected from evil-minded people. I trust the Holy Lord. Bless and save. Amen".

The slander is repeated until the candle goes out from the scissors. Magic words attract luck, which will be needed in court. A conspiracy is being read for himself and the person who is the plaintiff in an important matter. A ritual will come in handy when a large monetary compensation is at stake.

Universal rites

One of the universal rites helps in the solution of monetary affairs. The most effective conspiracies are read:

An effective rite will allow you to win in any case, whether it be a civil lawsuit or a monetary proceeding. If a person is guilty, but wants to avoid punishment, a universal ceremony will also help.

To win, speak a handkerchief. This is a simple little thing that is bought before the rite. A white handkerchief is chosen, a symbol of purity, especially if the conspirator is guilty and tries to avoid punishment. At night, after the sun sets, the attribute speaks with special words:

“I will arise, servant of God (name) in the morning, blessed, I will go out of the doors of my relatives crossing myself. I go from door to door, from door to gate, from gate to pure field I’ll leave. I will become in a wide field, and there the steel locks, the damask locks, the gates are huge. I will arise, the servant of God (name) between those constipations, I will lay a golden crown on my head - a clear month. Nothing will come to me too much, nothing will fall on my beloved. Everything that is controversial towards the month goes away, everything that is useful comes to me. May it be so. Amen".

The plot is repeated three times, after which the conspirator goes to bed and does not speak with anyone until the morning. At court, a scarf is used at any opportunity. It is impossible to give the enchanted object into the wrong hands, otherwise the matter cannot be won. The conspiracy helps the court justify the beloved: the charmed scarf is put into the man’s pocket. Such magic is effective if conscience is tortured, and it is necessary to complete a lengthy process in court that morally exhausts a person.

For conspiracy you will need a clean white shawl

An effective rite that will help resolve the matter in your favor is held on a handful of salt. On the eve of the trial, you need to pour a little salt in the saucer, and sprinkle it with holy water. Then a candle is burned (any that turned out to be at home), while it burns, the salt begins to burn:

“For a clear month I will put the sun red, the sun light, no one will be angry with me, no one will be upset with me, no one will be angry with the clear sun. I fall asleep with salt, I urge success. All the bad things are left on the saucer, I'm saving myself. Amen".

At the trial, a little salt is poured into a pocket, a pinch is eaten. Such actions will help to avoid the “bitterness” of the trial.

Water is a universal conductor. Many conspiracies are carried out on her (she stores the necessary charge of energy). In the early morning, before the dawn of the sun, the conspirator takes out a glass of clean water and reads the text above it:

“You, voditsa, are pure, transparent, like my conscience. No one is upset with me, neither kings, but queens, neither worldly courts, nor the whole Orthodox world. They will be before me, like a leaf before the grass, below the mowed grass, below the low water. Misfortune tortured me, but she retreated. My heaven is the key, the earth is the castle, I’m locking my words so that no one can open. As said, it will come true. Amen".

After that, the conspirator is baptized on all 4 cardinal points and drinks 12 sips of water. A ritual is held every morning, while the whole trial lasts. You can spend it at night, referring not to the rising sun, but to the moon.

Litigation is a difficult stage of life for both the plaintiff and the defendant. To speed up the process and obtain the desired result, white magic is used. It is safe and will not do any harm. With the help of universal and special conspiracies, luck, the favor of the judge and good monetary compensation are attracted. A ritual is conducted secretly from strangers: secrecy is a guarantee of the effectiveness of the rite. Simple attributes are used to enhance the plot: a handkerchief, water or salt. A homemade amulet is being prepared for protection.